Is AI Making Us Dumb? A 30-Minute Python Test Revealed Everything

"Can you write a Python program to check for a prime number?"

I asked my cousin this simple question last weekend. She's in her 4th semester, studying computer science, getting solid grades.

"Yes, I can," she said confidently.

I handed her my laptop and sat back to watch.

30 minutes later...

She finally solved it. But here's what shocked me—she struggled with basic logic that should be second nature to any CS student.

Curious, I asked her, "How have you made it this far in college?"

She smiled and gave me an answer that changed how I think about education:

"ChatGPT."

The Uncomfortable Truth

That moment hit me like a brick wall.

Here's someone who's "learning" programming but can't solve a basic problem without AI assistance. She's getting good grades, impressing professors, and heading toward a tech career.

But does she actually understand what she's doing?

This isn't just about my cousin. This is about an entire generation that's growing up with AI as their intellectual crutch.

And it's making me ask the big question: Are we creating a generation of smart people who can't think?

The AI Dependency Crisis

Let's be honest about what's happening:

In universities:

• Students use ChatGPT for assignments
• Copy-paste code without understanding logic
• Graduate with degrees but lack problem-solving skills

In workplaces:

• Junior developers can't debug without AI
• Writers struggle to form original thoughts
• Professionals panic when tools go down

In daily life:

• We can't remember phone numbers (thanks, smartphones)
• GPS killed our sense of direction
• Google destroyed our ability to retain information

The pattern is clear: Every time we outsource thinking to machines, we lose a piece of our intellectual independence.

But Wait... Is This Actually Bad?

Before we panic, let's step back.

Calculators didn't make mathematicians stupid. They freed them to solve bigger problems.

Word processors didn't ruin writers. They eliminated tedious retyping and enabled better editing.

Search engines didn't kill research skills. They made information accessible to everyone.

So maybe the question isn't "Is AI making us dumb?"

Maybe it's "Are we using AI dumbly?"

The Two Types of AI Users

I've noticed people fall into two camps:

The Dependent Users (The Dangerous Path)

• Use AI as a replacement for thinking
• Copy without understanding
• Panic when AI isn't available
• Result: Become intellectually weaker over time

The Augmented Users (The Smart Path)

• Use AI as a thinking partner
• Understand before implementing
• Can function independently
• Result: Become intellectually stronger with AI's help

The difference? Dependent users let AI think FOR them. Augmented users use AI to think WITH them.

The Real Problem (And It's Not AI)

Here's what I realized watching my cousin struggle:

The problem isn't that AI exists. The problem is that we're not teaching people HOW to think alongside it.

We're teaching students to use tools without building the fundamental skills to understand what those tools are doing.

It's like teaching someone to drive using only cruise control and wondering why they crash when they need to brake.

The Skills AI Can't Replace (Yet)

While AI gets better at everything, these human abilities remain irreplaceable:

Critical Thinking

• Questioning assumptions
• Spotting logical fallacies
• Connecting unrelated concepts

Creative Problem-Solving

• Finding novel approaches
• Thinking outside conventional frameworks
• Combining ideas in unexpected ways

Contextual Understanding

• Reading between the lines
• Understanding human emotions and motivations
• Adapting to unique situations

Learning How to Learn

• Recognizing knowledge gaps
• Asking the right questions
• Building on foundational concepts

The Smart Way to Use AI (Without Losing Your Mind)

For Students:

• Use AI to explain concepts you don't understand
• Ask AI to quiz you on what you've learned
• Have AI review your logic before you implement
• But always code the first draft yourself

For Professionals:

• Use AI for brainstorming and getting unstuck
• Let AI handle repetitive tasks while you focus on strategy
• Ask AI to challenge your assumptions and poke holes in your ideas
• But always understand what you're implementing

For Everyone:

• Treat AI like a really smart intern - helpful but needs supervision
• Use AI to amplify your thinking, not replace it
• Practice thinking without AI regularly (like mental exercise)
• Stay curious about HOW things work, not just THAT they work

The 30-Minute Challenge

Want to test yourself? Try this:

Pick a skill you use AI for regularly. Writing, coding, analysis, whatever.

Set a timer for 30 minutes.

Do that task without any AI assistance.

How did you feel? Frustrated? Lost? Or energized by the challenge?

Your answer tells you whether you're using AI as a crutch or a tool.

The Future We're Building

Here's my prediction:

In 10 years, there will be two types of professionals:

1. The AI-Dependent: Can't function when technology fails, limited by what AI can do
2. The AI-Augmented: Use AI to achieve superhuman results while retaining core thinking skills

Which one do you want to be?

Your Action Plan (Starting This Week)

Monday: Identify one area where you're overly dependent on AI

Tuesday: Practice that skill for 30 minutes without any AI help

Wednesday: Use AI to learn something new, but make sure you understand the fundamentals

Thursday: Teach someone else what you learned (teaching reveals gaps in understanding)

Friday: Reflect on what you've learned about your own thinking process

The Bottom Line

AI isn't making us dumb.

But using AI without thinking is.

The goal isn't to avoid AI—that's impossible and stupid. The goal is to stay smarter than the tools we use.

My cousin taught me something important that day: The real skill isn't knowing how to use AI. It's knowing when NOT to.

Because at the end of the day, AI can help you think faster, but it can't teach you how to think better.

That's still on you.

How do you balance using AI tools while maintaining your own thinking skills? I'm genuinely curious about your strategies—drop a comment below and let's figure this out together.

‍